Saturday, I went to the Peace March in Richmond, an action organized by Kiki Poe, and Elecia Holland in support of the Richmond High School student who was gang-raped by 10 boys/men, while approximately 20 others watched, took photos, mocked, and encouraged the rapists. I went because of course, I want to show solidarity with the young woman, with ALL women, but I also wanted to see what the conversation was going to be about, and then maybe put my own two cents in to make sure it at least included getting men to take responsibility.
About two hundred people showed up, frustratingly, only a small handful were actually from Richmond, the rest were from Oakland, and surrounding areas. I was, however, excited to see a few men with their children, and some young men (Dennis Kim from Youth Speaks) saying things which other men/boys really need to hear.
As usual though, there was some defensiveness. A man felt it necessary to express to me, that he felt it was divisive of me to call men out on rape culture, to hold men specifically accountable for male violence against women. I stood there talking with/listening to him for about 20 minutes, while he explained that mothers of the boys who don't have male role models are responsible too, that they need to make better choices, etc. He feels strongly that the conversation should not just be on what men can do, but what women can do as well. I told him that to a certain degree I agree that women can make better choices, we can ALL make better choices, but when violence against women is the topic of conversation, EVERYONE has been and continues to talk incessantly about the role women can play in male violence against women, including other women, men, the media, women's advocate groups and organizations, etc. I told him that the larger focus has been and continues to be on what women can do, when it should be on what men can and will do. He was defensive, he sees his participation in the march as proof that he's not a rapist, so we don't really need to be calling him out. This is not an uncommon response. Men do NOT want to see themselves as part of the problem, they don't want to see that they DO benefit from the violent, and brutal actions of their brothers, much the same way many, many white folks will get defensive when the issue of white privilege comes up. This guy absolutely did not want to be considered part of the group which terrorizes women and children, I can understand that, BUT until these men who see themselves as allies, yet don't do the simple (however painful) task of owning that they benefit from the violent oppression of women, they can't really be allies at all, in fact, because all their defensiveness does is drain us, and distract from the real issue, they are actually helping their brothers, they are making an active contribution to the culture of rape.
Another example of defensiveness came when a photo of me holding a sign which reads RAPE is a Men's Issue, was posted on facebook, and the only thing some guy had to say about it was "men are raped all the time." My response was this "1 in 6 women/girls are raped/sexually assaulted. 1 in 33 men/boys are raped/sexually assaulted. 99% of rapes/sexual assaults are perpetrated by men. Rape is not a women's issue, by and large, we do not make the choice to rape, men do, ergo, rape (and male violence against women) is a men's issue." He, like many men (as well as the many women who care about the men in their lives) just doesn't want to see that men rape women so often that there is actually a culture of rape, that women have had to developed coping skills (which do not prevent male violence, they just lesson the odds of being the ones attacked), not only to deal with the reality of being preyed upon, but to deal with our fear around it. And he sure doesn't want to own that he is part of the group who has created this rape culture. Again, I get that it is painful to be on the same team as those who perpetrate violence towards women and children, but no amount of blaming the other guy, or disassociating himself from those "other" guys, is gonna get him off that team, there is only one way to NOT be on that team, and that is to stop/prevent male violence towards women.
I don't hate men, there are many ways to see evidence of this, I don't rape men, I don't beat them, I don't use degrading language about them, I don't dehumanize them, I don't allow others to use degrading or dehumanizing language about them in my presence, I don't kidnap them, I don't murder them, I don't deny them equal pay, equal access to health care, education, or employment opportunities, I don't stalk them, I don't pressure them for sex, I don't engage in advertising campaigns about what their bodies should and should not look like, which involves a standard nearly impossible to meet without the use of starvation, surgery, and many artificial methods, and the list goes on. Despite this, when I, or pretty much any woman speaks out about the role men play in male violence towards women, and the role they must play to end/prevent that violence, the defensiveness becomes deafening, and then the next thing that happens is that that show-stopping term "man-hater" comes out. This is what so often stops the conversation, especially if the woman speaking is a lesbian, but it is just another distraction from the real issue, and the guy throwing it out there is actively engaged in shutting down the conversation, which means he is actually helping his brothers (those other guys, the ones who rape, etc) out, 'cos if I'm a man-hater then he/men is/are excused from listening to me, or any woman who expects men to step up and end/prevent male violence towards women. No, I don't hate men, but can most men, by their actions, say that they don't hate me/women?
What I say to women is, don't allow this to happen, don't allow yourselves to be distracted from holding men responsible, don't rush to the defense of the men/boys in your lives, when the role of men in male violence is talked about. First of all, holding them responsible, and accountable is not an attack on them, and second they don't need your help, most of them are already defending themselves.
To men, I say to hell with opening women's doors or helping them put on their coats, we can do these things for ourselves, quite easily. If you really want to do something to show a woman she is special to you, and that you are a man of worth, then organize actions against male violence, get active in getting other men to help stop/prevent violence, do whatever you can to help make this a safer world for her. Take your children to actions and activities where the focus is ending male violence, with as much enthusiasm, and consistency as you have when taking them to monster truck rallies, football games, fishing, etc. Educate yourselves, and your children in recognizing the hatred of women in your daily lives, and do everything you can to replace it with respect for ALL human beings, regardless of gender, sexual orientation, ethnic, class, or religious background. And when, as with JD, or the high school student, women ARE attacked, do all that you can to support the woman who was hurt, donate your money/time, and get your male peers to donate theirs (99% of the money raised for JD has come from women, the ones who can least afford the money, where are all the men who say they care?). Do it loudly, and proudly, every day in front of your children, and then they and others will know you for being a decent human being, as well as how to be decent human beings themselves. Do this, and you will have what seems to be profoundly absent in men today...honor. The role of men in ending male violence towards women, MUST be proactive, it must be fierce, and it must be consistent, or nothing will change.
There is now a way to make automatic monthly payments of $10/month by clicking on the subscribe button, it takes two minutes tops to do. If you'd like to have a larger or smaller amount set up, then please let me know at tallonsong@aol.com. : )
Thank-you to all who are fighting this brutal war against women, thank-you for helping to support JD, your courage and compassion are deeply appreciated, and much admired.